Tuesday, September 16, 2008

The Great Ganders of Gorgias

Initally, I find myself on Socrate's side of the conversation. I find him to be much more reasonable in the conversation than Gorgias. He is constantly asking Gorgias about his expertise, but Gorgias refuses to give a complete, fufilling answer. It is frustrating to read for it lingers on for quite some time.

Polus differs from Gorgias because he simply complies to whatever Socrates says. He never truly gives his opinion unless he is bickering or contrasting what Socrates states. However, in the most simple of terms, Socrates says that to do wrong is much worse that a wrongdoing. Polus says that a wrongdoing is much worse than to do wrong.

Socrates believes this because he thinks that a mental state is more important than a physical one. If one can be psychologically sound, then he or she will be healthy. Polus believes that a wrongdoing can harm or possibly kill you, thus is much worse than to do wrong.

I find this specific argument to be most interesting, because both provide sufficient reasoning for their conclusions. I also find the conversation about rhetoric to be intriguing. Gorgias mentions that if one is familiar with a rhetoric, he or she need not know any other expertise.

An argument I think Gorgias could have made would have been to actually expand on his expertise. He never actually stated what is was that he professed in. It leaves Socrates to a state of confusion and misunderstanding.

Monday, September 15, 2008

Work to live vs. Live to work

Abigail Zuger wrote a piece called "Defining a Doctor" in which she focuses on two young doctors and their ways of working in the field. There is a man who never works a minute later than his hours declare, only performs his specified duties, and has no emotional attachments to any patients. The woman often works overtime to complete a job or fufil a patient's needs, uses her free time at home to check up on patients, and usually does work outside of what is asked of her.

The question here is does the medical field need more of the "male doctor" type or the "woman doctor". Although there may be no difference in the chances of the different patients getting well, what doctor would one reccommend if he or she was becoming ill? The man completes his job to an end and is well rested while the woman finds no ends in her responsibilities and is constantly sleep deprived.

In my opinion, the medical field is seeing a large decrease in the type of the woman doctor. Many people focus so much on their text books and studies, that there is no time for external work these days. Not only does the woman clearly work harder than the man, but she has an emotional attachment to her job as well. As much as I think that the woman would make a better doctor, I think this world can only accept the man. He still knows what he is doing and has a healthier mental mind than the woman.

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

College for thought

To observe the different reasons why people invest so much time and money in college is managable for me at this point in my life because it has been 90 percent of what I have been thinking about throughout the day (the other 10 being strict schoolwork). However, by observing others surrounding me, I have realized that my own motives for a college education differs greatly from that of many others. I see this college experience as strictly to further my career and encourage independent living, which are both equally essential for a successful future.

Many other reasons some go to college can range from a new social experience to an excuse to move away from home to the mere fact that someone made you. Although some of these reasons may be preassumed, I do know friends and acquaintances who model after these reasons. I would also assume that for those who find a college experience to be more social than academic re-evaluate their college lives hopefully by their sophomore or junior year, right when they realize this stuff is serious.

The time and money spent here can either develop a career or waste one. I am fortunate enough to have parents willing to pay the costs of college and give me a hefty role of taking responsibility for my own actions. For this matter, I realize that my parents have let me go with a head start and left me to fend for myself now. There is no safety net at the end of my college education. After junior high, one had high school to catch up. In high school, one had the option of a college education. Now, the options are limited and I feel I must make the most of this experience now in order to feel secure at the end of four years.

The one part of the description of this first year seminar that intrigued me the most was the idea that we could be, or have the bold option to be, successful beyond the four years we spend here at Drake. The class should inspire us how to make the most of the education being offered. I am still yet to find the golden answer on how to do this, but i believe it is a growing process. Maybe I respond to this blog again in 4 plus years :)

Thursday, September 4, 2008

Invisible Intellectuality

The three pieces by Dweck, Perkins, and Ritchhart are very thought provoking. All the theories have valid points and can apply to all of us. We can now begin to think and act differently in all situations with Dweck's different types of knowledge, Perkins's theories on intelligence and goals, and Ritchhart's view on intellectual character. I believe that Dweck and Perkins most easily coincide together to support Ritchhart's theories. Proactive knowlege and learning goals will most likely lead to being an the best intellectual character you can be. Although, these are also the most difficult to achieve.

Intellectuality cannot be taught. It is not sufficiently explained in textbooks, professors, or even philosophers. Someone's own intellectual charcter is just that- their own. It must come through experience and learning all different aspects of the world.

From a personal standpoint, I believe that the education that I have had thus far in my life has encouraged this type of character as best as it can. I have studied topics from freshman literature to argumentation and debate to advanced calculus. It is clear that many of us have studied a broad spectrum of ideas and topics. However, I am almost certain that no one has ever seen a class on the basis of how to be a better person or a class dedicated in intellectual personalities. This is because I believe it is all a package deal.

In any class you take, the mind is always processing information. In many cases, the information is new and hard to comprehend, and the mind forces you to cope and find a way to understand. This builds character- whether it be intellectual character or not, thats for the future to decide. I learned at one point in my education how to implicitly differentiate a quadratic formula. I can't say that I could easily do that again within a few seconds as I could before or that I will ever need to after four years, but I can say that my mind is now trainied to do complicated work and stretch itself. Sure, intellectuality isn't all about mental capacity, it is about being curious as well. And I think that if we have already be trained in school to stretch our minds, then our brain is figuratively bigger and open for new information.

So, no, intellectual character is not and can not be directly taught in a classroom, or anywhere. It simply creeeps up on you without making a sound, hoping for you to take advantage of it.

Monday, September 1, 2008

Excerpts from Dweck

The material presented by Dweck was very interesting and concerning to me. After reading, I made several inferences about my learning styles. The one theory on intelligence that struck me the most was the malleable intelligence. As much as I want to say that I have acquired this learning style, I find some aspects of my intelligence in an "entity theory". I feel successful after completing anything, whether it be a one hundred page story in fine print or a page of addition and subtraction. However, I do appreciate a challenge and feel much more rewarded if it entails a vast amount of thinking.

I believe that teachers encourage more of a malleable intelligence. Education is a constant upgrade. The material gets harder, forcing you to step outside a comfort zone, thus think intellectually. At points in earlier education, however, "busy work" was assigned much more often encouraging a fixed intelligence.

As I have (hopefully) matured, I know that I am more atttracted to learning goals rather than performance goals. In an ever-changing society, there is so much to keep up with and no time to be static with information. We must constantly be acquiring intelligence just to keep up. For the mere fact that I will also be completely on my own soon, I need to be forming learning goals to suceed in a business corporated world.

Overall, I find Dweck's viewpoints to be all well researched. Her theories of intelligence are very reinforcing with various studies. However, it is difficult to pick one theory of intelligence for yourself because of the way she disregards the entity theory. In my opinion, everyone will be drawn to take the route of saying they are a product of the incremental theory, when in reality too many are the latter.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Understanding how to understand

As an overall perspective on David Perkins's "Beyond Understanding", I felt that the article was very intellectual and thought provoking. I am unsure whether I will ever fully be able to grasp what Perkins is trying to explain, for the article is extremely in depth and acquires a very mature tone that calls for several reviews of various paragraphs. However, once several peers and I were able to take on a broad perspective of his article, we were able to then apply it to our lives.

One intriguing part that Perkins mentions is how we are being educated today in the world and how it is affecting our knowledge for the present and future. As a student, I agree with his thought that we are only reaching the second stage of knowledge because few teachers tend to go deeper into the most important topics in life. However, I don't understand how he imagines the world of education ever being able to reach the proactive stage, for it is extremely difficult to teach in a classroom.

A final opinion that I want to share on this topic is that I feel society may be prematurely judged by those such as Perkins. It is possible that people still going through their education do not have the physical ability to think and act on such a high level. Like in every theory of psychological development, as people get older, their thought processes and perceptions become more intellectual and detailed. This is not to say, however, that we all have excuses for incompetence and immaturity, but some may not be as developed as the world would like. Maybe give our generation a few more years and re-evaluate.