Wednesday, October 1, 2008

If 'Virtuity' was a word, I would use it here.

Instead of getting right into emphasizing one of Aristotle's virtues, I would rather list them out first for my own sake to make sure I have comprehended them to the best of my ability...please assist me if there are other aspects to his virtues that I have missed or misrepresented.

Aristotle says we much act on that which our soul desires. The soul, thus, has five aspects in which it "has truth through affirmation and denial".

I. Technical Expertise: "productive disposition accompanied by true rational prescription"- One must produce something or bring it about by practce and theory. We must intially focus on the production of a project rather than the final outcome, and we must use reasonable processes otherwise it will be a false representation of the soul's desire.

II. Systematic Knowledge: "It is eternal and without qualification. It is teachable an capable of being learned." This is the knowledge that is by demonstration- knowledge that is already known.

III. Wisdom: "a disposition accompanied by rational prescription, true, in the sphere of human goods, relating to action." Wisdom is a kind of excellence. It cannot be touched or forgotten. It is not action or deliberation, but pure action relating to human good.

IV. Intellectual Accomplishment: "It is a combination of systematic knowledge and intelligence." :I need more time with this one:

V. Intelligence: I believe that intelligence is simply the object of all the other's starting points.


I cannot declare which one of Aristotle's virtues are most valid or even relatable, for I do not know if I can describe them well enough at this point. With more discussion and review, I believe I may be able to contribute more to the virtues.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Aristotle, afterward

Aristotle focuses on excellence, and how we can and should strive for it. I will try my best to analyze his work, for it was difficult for me to figure out his exact meanings behind each section. First, I believe that Aristotle makes the connection of being excellent (virtuous) to having a happy (fufilled) life. He delves into the idea that happiness of the soul is equivalent to excellence. I suppose that he would mean that if can activate what the desires of our soul entail, we will become virtuous.

In order to achieve this fufillment, we must become excellent not by natural dispositions but by habituation. In other words, we must first "engage ourselves in an activity" rather than let the activity force an engagement upon us. For example, we must force ourselves to read a novel out of interest rather than wait upon a teacher to tell us to.

Aristotle also writes multiple times about contrasting ideas such as pleasure and pain, deficiency and excess, and rashness and cowardice. I do not think that he speaks about one characteristic over the other symbolizing excellence, but rather than finding a just and moderate in between. However, he also believes that the excessive state is more contrary to moderation because it is these that we are more drawn to- thus create a natur-istic (?) habit. When we should create a habitual habit.

I do agree with Aristotle in that the closer we come to finding the characteristics of our soul, we will find fufillment. This is because I believe to act on intuition is greatest. Aristotle mentions that we must first engage on an activity to become excellent and virtuous. I agree with this, but we also must listen to ourselves and what can bring our soul to life.

I feel like there are a lot of contrasting ideas that Aristotle mentions, many of which were slightly confusing and will be much more effectful if discussed in class!

A final judgement call

So, after yesterday, I still haven't come to a conclusion on whether seeking the truth is more fufilling than living in stagnant happiness. However, I have thought more about the negative and positive effects of both situations.
In the case of living a routine life, with complete satisfaction, there will never be any challenge or something to thrive for. However, one will forever be happy. Why change that?

Now, the other side of the discussion- searching for truth seems to bring more argument. In my view, most of the time when a person goes seeking for the truth or seeking for something better, the person gets hurt. Take, for example, Michael Jackson and Ana Carolina Reston. Jackson is someone who continually believes that he can look better and there is always something he can fix to make his life better. Look at him now, he looks like an emaciated animal. He may think that he looks healthy, but his body definately is not. Ana Carolina Reston is another example who has taken seeking the truth to an extreme. Reston was a Brazilian model who suffered from anorexia. I use the past tense because she literally starved herself to death. She is not the only example of a person who believes his or her life can be better if they were only a bit skinnier. She continually thought that she could be thinner and more beautiful, even at the point of sheer skin and bones. Again, she may have thought she was healthy, but she evidently was not.

Of course these are some extreme examples, but more and more people everyday fall victim to these types of situations. The phrase "you can never be too rich or too thin" symbolizes a part of this longing for something better. If we are always searching for something that is not there, that we think might be just a little bit better, we can really hurt ourselves- physically and emotionally.

Monday, September 22, 2008

I Dream of Gorgias

The title just seemed to roll off the tongue well and I suppose with all of the thought on the play and life inquiries, the title is sufficient. Anyways, after looking over my post about a week or so ago, I know that whatever I believe to be indicative of time and money well spent has not greatly changed. In a broad perspective, that is. In specifics, I think that my views are a bit different.

I am tempted to believe that a self-fufilled lifestyle would be most indicative of time and money well spent. By this, I mean that by the end of one's college career, he or she is living a life that makes him or her happy. Well what makes them happy? We discussed this in class quite a bit, and I think that it comes down to something you do that feel good about. And when this occurs, there is no denying it. People can ask, "why do you feel so content?" And I believe that sometimes you just know- there is that sentimental feeling/emotion that one can acquire. It is rare, but it is there.

A few weeks ago, I would have thougt that more hands-on aspects of life would be indicative of time and money well spent- things like a well-paying, successful job perhaps. However, I did believe that one must be content with what he or she is doing, which is what I believe now as well.

In order to be wise, I think that one needs to accept all possibilities of life. I cannot narrow my focus on only one thing. Even though I mentioned before that I need to do only what makes me happy, I think that in order to be wise, we can still do these things but experience others as well. For instance, if eating peanut butter and jelly sandwhices make me happy (which of course they do), I could broaden my perspective on the sandwhich and use a different kind of bread. Now, I am more knowledgeable about what else can make the sandwhich. Of course this may be an odd way to approach wisdom, but who ever said there was only one meaning to wisdom? In order for us to be wise, we must acknowledge all aspects of life.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

The truth hurts..

After today's discussion in class, I couldn't help but think about the idea of whether or not I should seek truth or dwell in a stagnant happiness and contentment. For the rest of the day, I have been back and forth several times on this strong topic of concern. The first aspect of this query that hits me is why should I change something that already makes me happy? Why fix what's not broke, right? Well then I start to think if there could be something better, or even more truthful and valuable, out there.

For instance, I have a very strong belief that a book I once read titled, "A Child Called It" by Dave Pelzer, is a true story and all the stories are based directly on his experiences with child abuse, with maybe a few minor tweaks here and there. One day when word got out that the book was fabricated, I refused to believe it because I had empathized with this child from the moment I started to read it and had put my heart into the book's two sequels. I felt so much emotion while reading this book that knowing the truth would in someway lessen the passion that I once felt. After class today, I realized that maybe it is not right to believe or have faith in something that makes you feel emotion if it's untrue; I feel like I would be deceiving myself. However, this also brings me to another very controversial, yet important topic.

Religion is ubiquitous in our society today, in so many different ways. There are so many different Gods, Deities, and faiths that people believe in or bow down to daily. But what if someone told a true believer of God that he wasn't real? And that there is a much better God or even there is no God? If someone with a rhetoric as powerful as Gorgias's could convince someone to believe the latter, it just seems to be wrong. Religion has such a strong influence on so many people that it just seems wrong to make oneself look for a better way of life if he or she is already content with a faith or God. Of course there are more minor matters of life which can change a person's view, like being told "The Hills" is staged. But in the end, I think it is still the same idea.

I have always believed in karma. If I do good, good things will happen to me. If I do wrong, bad things will happen to me. But again, after today, we've realized that even those who lie, cheat, and steal can have good things happen to them if they can get away with their criminal acts. So what is the point of always being moral? I suppose to have an intrinsic fufillment- But does that bring success? This is a very concerning topic to me, and I feel that it will take more than a few days to realize what the right answer is..or if there is one.

A Varied Vocation

In Will Campbell's "Vocation as Grace", he accounts on a time in which he asked a circus man why he did what he did. Aside from him saying that it was a rush of adrenaline and good pay, the man said he did it because his family was up there with him. So Campbell asks, "But why do they stay up there?" The man replies by saying, "Because I drink too much!"

In this segment Campbell is challenging the 'conventional Christian notion' that a vocation relies purely on oneself. In this case, he believes that we depend on others and others depend on us for strong impulses and callings. For the circus man, he was dependent and reliant on his family every night due to his frequent intoxicated self. If it weren't for them, he could be dead.

I concur with Campbell in the sense that others have a major influence on how we are inspired to act or live. If it was just a world with ourselves, we would have nothing to relate to or model after. Also, it is much more enjoyable to interact with others than to be limited to a monotonous lifestlye.

Plato and justice

In the final half of "Gorgias", the topic of justice and virtue is discussed between Socrates and Callicles. Callicles believes that the most powerful and better ones of a community can acquire control over inferiors. Socrates believes in a natural justice is which everyone deserves equal opportunities.

One of Callicle's strongest arguments is that which regards to the pleasure/pain argument. He thinks that it is most pleasurable to realease oneself of all pain and restraints. This will inevitably allow one's desires to grow without a limitation.

Socrates strongest argument consists of his analysis on how to live the fullest life. He concurs that one must act in the name of purity and wellness (or good) in all situations. One must by strong, healthy and promote justice in his or her life to fufull a lifetime.

Although this was written over 2000 years ago, I believe that Plato's work is still relevant today. With a ubiquitous topic such as this one, many will indefinately keep analyzing their lives. I believe that Socrates contributes the best arguments and ideals on the discussion, for he is most confident and less likely to concur with the opposition. I found "Gorgias" to be slightly confusing in certain areas merely for the style of speech. With a deep analysis, however, I was able to sometimes find a valuable virtue to look up to.