In Shanley's "Doubt: a parable", I have only encountered more difficulty on evaluating and analyzing my lifestyle. Although I try to be as unselfish as possible (which I greatly want to work on!), I still find myself attributing the messages and theories of all the pieces our class has read to my own habits rather than the nature of others. Consciously averting that habit of mine, I found "Doubt" to be relatable to many. It was said in the dialogue, by Father Flynn I believe (could be mistaken), that it takes much more courage to be doubtful than to be certain, for certainty is definite, while doubt is infinite.
Throughout the play, Sister Aloysius seems to be certain of Flynn's intentions. Although provided with no evidence, she remains confident in her convictions. However, in the final scene, she makes a remark to Sister James that she has doubts. I was able to relate this final scene, as well as my whole analysis of the play, to our class. Often times, one of us is certain we know the answer or have a valid response to an inquiry. We are almost always asked to show evidence. Without any evidence of our proclamations, they are only certain to us on an intermediate level, yet doubtful to others.
The questions of who I sympathize with most and who I admire most intrigue me. I sympathize with Sister James most, for she seems to be most like me, yet is criticized. If I were to uphold a teaching position, I would want my students to enjoy the class and be able to come to me with any concerns. I also want to please others to whom I work for and with. However, I admire Sister Aloysius most, for she is strong and intelligent. She sticks to her convictions without true evidence because it is what she believes and what she thinks to be right. If I could have the courage to model her behavior I would. However, all the others (Sister James, Mrs. Muller, Father Flynn) seem to either despise her or be frightened of her. So the question I ask myself is would I rather be able to have confident convictions and beliefs that can aid in pivotal situations, or would I rather be innocent in a cruel world to avoid all difficulties and wicked looks? Oh, I have doubts, I have such doubts.
Monday, November 17, 2008
Saturday, November 15, 2008
Lon Larson
After just an hour with Lon Larson, a cancer patient survivor, I realized that maybe blogging everyday and a few homework assignments don't exactly lead up to a very stressful lifestyle that I thought I had. What I thought would be a typical speech about living life to the fullest turned into an emotional story about how one man with circumstances far worse than those that I seem to suffer forms every minute of his life with the best possible attitude he can create. One note that he mentioned was that he was "the luckiest man alive". I second guessed myself when I heard him speak about this. How could a man given 3-6 months to live consider himself to be so lucky? As Lon gave me chills with his story and attitude and optimistic lifestyle, I realized that I can wake up every day and not only be thankful for those whom I grace and grace me. It is imperative to realize that someone can make a meaningful impression on your life, as well as you on them. It is difficult to put into words what Lon Larson's story did for me, for it is mostly emotionally inspiring. Although he said that he does not consider himself a motivational speaker, I feel that he is nothing short of one. I wish the best for Lon Larson, and hope he continues to live the greatest lifestyle for however long it may be for him.
Thursday, November 13, 2008
The long awaited one...
Considering my blog postings have gathered a month's long dust, I presume it to be necessary that I reflect upon the past month, as succinct as possible.
As half of the class adventured on the concept/meaning of "The Sparrow" with me, we decided to conclude upon the idea of faith. However, this only led us to a struggle in grasping the concept of faith. In broad terms, faith is to believe or to have trust in an uncertain entity. Some would say that faith can dictate a sufficient and meaningful life because you can give all your trust and hope into it, which is fufilling in itself. In "The Sparrow", Emilio had faith in the crew that was sent to space with him. He also had a faith in God that would aid his trip. After coming home with his faith shattered at the death of his friends, Emilio was forced to reconstruct his beliefs again to same strength they were at pre-trip. This idea of losing trust due to unfortunate events is evident in modern day among all christians, catholics, jews, muslims, athiests, agnostics, etc. Everyone has moments that tests their true beliefs. It seems to be, however, it is about how you can put things in perspective after a moment of betrayl even if the situation does not change.
In the "Grand Inquisitor", I found the ideas between Ivan and Zossima to not be completely similar but radically different. Ivan spoke of the Grand Inquistor's ideas on freedom and happiness; the two do not come together. Zossima then contrasts freedom and isolation. These men speak in terms of religion, but a perspective beyond religion can be formed. Human nature is described in the book. It is human nature to desire and cherish the freedom we are given, but in its simplest terms, it is not what we want. To be free, we are independent from others, we are independent from forced decisions, and independent from happiness. Although we may search and plead for freedom, we would rather want decisions to be made for us and someone to follow. However, when Ivan approaches the prisoner, Jesus, he condemns him for manipulating the people into thinking they were free, when really they were following him only because it is what their natural needs inclined for. However, I feel that if people are truly content with following another and feel free, then why detest it? Sometimes I want someone to follow, it shows me there is a path for me. Although there are also times of indepence that strike in me and I want to be a nonconformist. To really evaluate the way I have lived in this sense in the past 18 years is difficult, even frustrating. I do not want to be happy yet be known as a follower at the same time. I want to be a leader, is this what Ivan is suggesting? Hard to tell.
"Doubt: A parable" is very thought provoking and leads to uncertainty, hence the "doubt". First, 'a parable' means a short story or an analogy. The play is concise, thus leads to a vast amount of uncertainty and questions. I like that the play brings several characters into the scenes, yet all of them seem to have doubt in some way. My evidence for this is Father Flynn temporarily has doubt in Sister James. Sister James doubts Father Flynn. Sister Aloysius doubts Father Flynn as well as Sister James. Mrs. Muller doubts the situation Sister Aloysius is presenting to her. Yet with this entity of doubt, no one seems to inevitably change. Although Father Flynn moves to another parish, he never confesses anything, leaving us and the rest to further doubt. I certainly have uncertainties in my life, but always seem to overlook them, as I find them a waste of time. I consider doubt to be a confusing topic for it is inevitable, yet never ending!
I feel as if I am becoming flustered and irritated by the fact that I have just embarked on more than my share of confusing intellectual topics for one hour. Perhaps I will start to blog more frequently to avoid this circumstance again.
As half of the class adventured on the concept/meaning of "The Sparrow" with me, we decided to conclude upon the idea of faith. However, this only led us to a struggle in grasping the concept of faith. In broad terms, faith is to believe or to have trust in an uncertain entity. Some would say that faith can dictate a sufficient and meaningful life because you can give all your trust and hope into it, which is fufilling in itself. In "The Sparrow", Emilio had faith in the crew that was sent to space with him. He also had a faith in God that would aid his trip. After coming home with his faith shattered at the death of his friends, Emilio was forced to reconstruct his beliefs again to same strength they were at pre-trip. This idea of losing trust due to unfortunate events is evident in modern day among all christians, catholics, jews, muslims, athiests, agnostics, etc. Everyone has moments that tests their true beliefs. It seems to be, however, it is about how you can put things in perspective after a moment of betrayl even if the situation does not change.
In the "Grand Inquisitor", I found the ideas between Ivan and Zossima to not be completely similar but radically different. Ivan spoke of the Grand Inquistor's ideas on freedom and happiness; the two do not come together. Zossima then contrasts freedom and isolation. These men speak in terms of religion, but a perspective beyond religion can be formed. Human nature is described in the book. It is human nature to desire and cherish the freedom we are given, but in its simplest terms, it is not what we want. To be free, we are independent from others, we are independent from forced decisions, and independent from happiness. Although we may search and plead for freedom, we would rather want decisions to be made for us and someone to follow. However, when Ivan approaches the prisoner, Jesus, he condemns him for manipulating the people into thinking they were free, when really they were following him only because it is what their natural needs inclined for. However, I feel that if people are truly content with following another and feel free, then why detest it? Sometimes I want someone to follow, it shows me there is a path for me. Although there are also times of indepence that strike in me and I want to be a nonconformist. To really evaluate the way I have lived in this sense in the past 18 years is difficult, even frustrating. I do not want to be happy yet be known as a follower at the same time. I want to be a leader, is this what Ivan is suggesting? Hard to tell.
"Doubt: A parable" is very thought provoking and leads to uncertainty, hence the "doubt". First, 'a parable' means a short story or an analogy. The play is concise, thus leads to a vast amount of uncertainty and questions. I like that the play brings several characters into the scenes, yet all of them seem to have doubt in some way. My evidence for this is Father Flynn temporarily has doubt in Sister James. Sister James doubts Father Flynn. Sister Aloysius doubts Father Flynn as well as Sister James. Mrs. Muller doubts the situation Sister Aloysius is presenting to her. Yet with this entity of doubt, no one seems to inevitably change. Although Father Flynn moves to another parish, he never confesses anything, leaving us and the rest to further doubt. I certainly have uncertainties in my life, but always seem to overlook them, as I find them a waste of time. I consider doubt to be a confusing topic for it is inevitable, yet never ending!
I feel as if I am becoming flustered and irritated by the fact that I have just embarked on more than my share of confusing intellectual topics for one hour. Perhaps I will start to blog more frequently to avoid this circumstance again.
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Ray Kroc
The segment in Leading Lives That Matter about three biological sketches is very interesting because it gives insight on three very different lives and journies. The first one I read was about Ray Kroc, founder of the fast food restaurant McDonalds. Now the actual story about his life is just what the main title suggests, a biography. It details the span of his life, how he came up with the idea, what McDonalds is like today, and so on. The interesting part however comes with the introduction to the three stories.
It says that Kroc was a typical "rags to riches" guy and asks the question if you would admire him more because of this. Do people admire these lives more than those who have been healthy their entire lives? Kroc did work his way up and became very successful. The story talks about his multiple jobs, many having nothing to do with his business, and how he finally got his break. I have never thought about this, but I do suppose that people admire the ones who fought for something rather than had it come naturally. However, don't the ones that have it come naturally also have to work hard at one point? In America, we love the underdog. We always want a story to fight for and come together about. Ray Kroc is your typical American story that has the nation cheering for him and not for someone like Paris Hilton.
Another story mentioned is about a young woman, Iris Chang, who was a Chinese-American writer and became interested in China's "Nanking Incident" after hearing about it. She wrote a vivid book on the mutilations and grieving stories that occured in Nanking in order to inform the public. Her work was considered to controversial and not credible, which caused Chang to be upset. Chang eventually killed herself perhaps feeling as though she had done too little. The question here after this story, is posed as asking is a life that is short-lived, yet self-sacrificial, more worthy than one that is long and 'comparatively undistinguished'?
In both cases for Kroc and Chang, there were qualities and benefits of their lives that made them better. It was fast food restaurants for Kroc and history for Chang. I believe that this has much to do with one's quality of living. If you can have a splendid life with the qualities that you work for or on then life will only be satisfying by the conclusions you find.
It says that Kroc was a typical "rags to riches" guy and asks the question if you would admire him more because of this. Do people admire these lives more than those who have been healthy their entire lives? Kroc did work his way up and became very successful. The story talks about his multiple jobs, many having nothing to do with his business, and how he finally got his break. I have never thought about this, but I do suppose that people admire the ones who fought for something rather than had it come naturally. However, don't the ones that have it come naturally also have to work hard at one point? In America, we love the underdog. We always want a story to fight for and come together about. Ray Kroc is your typical American story that has the nation cheering for him and not for someone like Paris Hilton.
Another story mentioned is about a young woman, Iris Chang, who was a Chinese-American writer and became interested in China's "Nanking Incident" after hearing about it. She wrote a vivid book on the mutilations and grieving stories that occured in Nanking in order to inform the public. Her work was considered to controversial and not credible, which caused Chang to be upset. Chang eventually killed herself perhaps feeling as though she had done too little. The question here after this story, is posed as asking is a life that is short-lived, yet self-sacrificial, more worthy than one that is long and 'comparatively undistinguished'?
In both cases for Kroc and Chang, there were qualities and benefits of their lives that made them better. It was fast food restaurants for Kroc and history for Chang. I believe that this has much to do with one's quality of living. If you can have a splendid life with the qualities that you work for or on then life will only be satisfying by the conclusions you find.
Wednesday, October 8, 2008
Endearing Devotions
I had to look up devotion, for I only knew the meaning in which someone is deeply committed to something. I found out that it can also mean a short religious service, which made more sense for the exercise.
If I were called upon to create a week-long devotion, I would likely use the theories and thoughts from Epictetus. For one, I found his work easier to comprehend than that of Aurelius. I happen to only look over the first two books of Aurelius and found myself relating more to Epictetus. This may be because Aurelius often speaks of what he has learned in a personal standpoint, which makes it harder to associate with a general lifestyle. The listing of Epictetus was easier to follow from the organization.
With that said, I thought that most of the points Epictetus made were valid to living a worthy lifestyle, but one really stood out to me. Number 13 which starts off by stating "if you want to improve, be content to be thought foolish and stupid with regard to external things." First, for a little background- this has always been one of my favorite quotes, and I feel like it defines parts of the way I live. I never knew that it was a renowned philosopher who said it because I picked it up from my favorite movie. Now that I know it was Epictetus who created the quote, it makes my decision easier to use this piece of The Enchiridion in my devotion.
Getting back to the concentration of the theme he presents, I think that it is not only important to accept eternal views, but it is also important to release some of your grasp on your natural conformed values. This is also among some of the topics that we have been discussing in class: Open your mind, go outside of your comfort zone, be curious, etc. And sometimes, it is important to understand that acting in these ways will not always be a societal status quo. People will stare and sometimes criticize, but like Epictetus said, you must be okay with that.
This would clearly be a modern version of the this theme that Epictetus presents, thus it may divert from his original perspective. On the issue of giving a title to the devotion, I don't know that I would have a specific name, but I would definitely attribute it to point 13. Not only am I content with his views on living happily, but I am ecstatic to finally know who said my favorite quote!
If I were called upon to create a week-long devotion, I would likely use the theories and thoughts from Epictetus. For one, I found his work easier to comprehend than that of Aurelius. I happen to only look over the first two books of Aurelius and found myself relating more to Epictetus. This may be because Aurelius often speaks of what he has learned in a personal standpoint, which makes it harder to associate with a general lifestyle. The listing of Epictetus was easier to follow from the organization.
With that said, I thought that most of the points Epictetus made were valid to living a worthy lifestyle, but one really stood out to me. Number 13 which starts off by stating "if you want to improve, be content to be thought foolish and stupid with regard to external things." First, for a little background- this has always been one of my favorite quotes, and I feel like it defines parts of the way I live. I never knew that it was a renowned philosopher who said it because I picked it up from my favorite movie. Now that I know it was Epictetus who created the quote, it makes my decision easier to use this piece of The Enchiridion in my devotion.
Getting back to the concentration of the theme he presents, I think that it is not only important to accept eternal views, but it is also important to release some of your grasp on your natural conformed values. This is also among some of the topics that we have been discussing in class: Open your mind, go outside of your comfort zone, be curious, etc. And sometimes, it is important to understand that acting in these ways will not always be a societal status quo. People will stare and sometimes criticize, but like Epictetus said, you must be okay with that.
This would clearly be a modern version of the this theme that Epictetus presents, thus it may divert from his original perspective. On the issue of giving a title to the devotion, I don't know that I would have a specific name, but I would definitely attribute it to point 13. Not only am I content with his views on living happily, but I am ecstatic to finally know who said my favorite quote!
Monday, October 6, 2008
Friend or Foe?
Aristotle's view on friendship is detailed and consists of many more layers than I would ever attribute to the quality. According to him, friendship can be separated in three categories. To the simplest interpretation of these categories, I came upon the first as being friends of usefulness. These are the friendships that we acquire only because another one is useful to our own fufillment or success. For example, businessmen often have these types of relationships because it is their main priority to excel in the business world, thus need to have friends that can aid in their path.
The next relationship Aristotle describes is one of pleasure. Sometimes, we form friendships that fufill a pleasurable instinct in us. For example, we often have friends that are witty and make us laugh or ones that like to talk about the same things we do. These friends and ones of usefulness are temporary, according to Aristotle. Because our pleasures and needs tend to change over time, any friend of ours that falls under these categories will no longer be necessary in our lives.
The third relationship that is mentioned is the purest form of friendship. It is one of "reciprocated good". This type of friendship has both parties seeking good from the other and thus returning it as well. It is said that this will always be a long lasting relationship.
From a personal view, I can agree with Aristotle, but I would have to slightly mend his points to equal mine. I believe that a true friend needs to fufill all three qualities that he mentioned. Of course this would be in a perfect world, but I find that when my personal needs or likes change, those of my best friends do too. In order to be friends, I do not think that it is necessary to know every aspect of someone's life, but it usually happens that way anyways. The best of friends are made over long periods of time.
Enemy is a harsh word, but I do believe they exist. I do not believe, however, that one should condemn another just because his or her friend has. But as I said before, it may just happen that way with the best of friends. A good reason to have an enemy, or someone you respect less that a good friend, would be if they have disrespected you in a way that demoralizes or patronizes you. If a true characteristic of someone makes you feel uncomfortable or upset, there is no reason to give full respect.
The last piece that I want to talk about is the issue of friendships with authority. Is it possible to be friends with your boss? Your teacher? Your coach? Your mom? I think that friendship is not the appropriate term for relationships such as these. According to Aristotle, he believes that the "loving should itself be proportionate." The better person, or person of more authority, or more useful one should recieve more respect from the other. I agree with this, but I still feel that there can always be a very strong relationship between these two parties. Authoritative family members especially deserve the upmost respect and a child should be the one who is disciplined. I do not think that friends can occur within authority, only shifts in respect. However, I am open to the views of others as well.
The next relationship Aristotle describes is one of pleasure. Sometimes, we form friendships that fufill a pleasurable instinct in us. For example, we often have friends that are witty and make us laugh or ones that like to talk about the same things we do. These friends and ones of usefulness are temporary, according to Aristotle. Because our pleasures and needs tend to change over time, any friend of ours that falls under these categories will no longer be necessary in our lives.
The third relationship that is mentioned is the purest form of friendship. It is one of "reciprocated good". This type of friendship has both parties seeking good from the other and thus returning it as well. It is said that this will always be a long lasting relationship.
From a personal view, I can agree with Aristotle, but I would have to slightly mend his points to equal mine. I believe that a true friend needs to fufill all three qualities that he mentioned. Of course this would be in a perfect world, but I find that when my personal needs or likes change, those of my best friends do too. In order to be friends, I do not think that it is necessary to know every aspect of someone's life, but it usually happens that way anyways. The best of friends are made over long periods of time.
Enemy is a harsh word, but I do believe they exist. I do not believe, however, that one should condemn another just because his or her friend has. But as I said before, it may just happen that way with the best of friends. A good reason to have an enemy, or someone you respect less that a good friend, would be if they have disrespected you in a way that demoralizes or patronizes you. If a true characteristic of someone makes you feel uncomfortable or upset, there is no reason to give full respect.
The last piece that I want to talk about is the issue of friendships with authority. Is it possible to be friends with your boss? Your teacher? Your coach? Your mom? I think that friendship is not the appropriate term for relationships such as these. According to Aristotle, he believes that the "loving should itself be proportionate." The better person, or person of more authority, or more useful one should recieve more respect from the other. I agree with this, but I still feel that there can always be a very strong relationship between these two parties. Authoritative family members especially deserve the upmost respect and a child should be the one who is disciplined. I do not think that friends can occur within authority, only shifts in respect. However, I am open to the views of others as well.
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
If 'Virtuity' was a word, I would use it here.
Instead of getting right into emphasizing one of Aristotle's virtues, I would rather list them out first for my own sake to make sure I have comprehended them to the best of my ability...please assist me if there are other aspects to his virtues that I have missed or misrepresented.
Aristotle says we much act on that which our soul desires. The soul, thus, has five aspects in which it "has truth through affirmation and denial".
I. Technical Expertise: "productive disposition accompanied by true rational prescription"- One must produce something or bring it about by practce and theory. We must intially focus on the production of a project rather than the final outcome, and we must use reasonable processes otherwise it will be a false representation of the soul's desire.
II. Systematic Knowledge: "It is eternal and without qualification. It is teachable an capable of being learned." This is the knowledge that is by demonstration- knowledge that is already known.
III. Wisdom: "a disposition accompanied by rational prescription, true, in the sphere of human goods, relating to action." Wisdom is a kind of excellence. It cannot be touched or forgotten. It is not action or deliberation, but pure action relating to human good.
IV. Intellectual Accomplishment: "It is a combination of systematic knowledge and intelligence." :I need more time with this one:
V. Intelligence: I believe that intelligence is simply the object of all the other's starting points.
I cannot declare which one of Aristotle's virtues are most valid or even relatable, for I do not know if I can describe them well enough at this point. With more discussion and review, I believe I may be able to contribute more to the virtues.
Aristotle says we much act on that which our soul desires. The soul, thus, has five aspects in which it "has truth through affirmation and denial".
I. Technical Expertise: "productive disposition accompanied by true rational prescription"- One must produce something or bring it about by practce and theory. We must intially focus on the production of a project rather than the final outcome, and we must use reasonable processes otherwise it will be a false representation of the soul's desire.
II. Systematic Knowledge: "It is eternal and without qualification. It is teachable an capable of being learned." This is the knowledge that is by demonstration- knowledge that is already known.
III. Wisdom: "a disposition accompanied by rational prescription, true, in the sphere of human goods, relating to action." Wisdom is a kind of excellence. It cannot be touched or forgotten. It is not action or deliberation, but pure action relating to human good.
IV. Intellectual Accomplishment: "It is a combination of systematic knowledge and intelligence." :I need more time with this one:
V. Intelligence: I believe that intelligence is simply the object of all the other's starting points.
I cannot declare which one of Aristotle's virtues are most valid or even relatable, for I do not know if I can describe them well enough at this point. With more discussion and review, I believe I may be able to contribute more to the virtues.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)