Thursday, September 18, 2008

Plato and justice

In the final half of "Gorgias", the topic of justice and virtue is discussed between Socrates and Callicles. Callicles believes that the most powerful and better ones of a community can acquire control over inferiors. Socrates believes in a natural justice is which everyone deserves equal opportunities.

One of Callicle's strongest arguments is that which regards to the pleasure/pain argument. He thinks that it is most pleasurable to realease oneself of all pain and restraints. This will inevitably allow one's desires to grow without a limitation.

Socrates strongest argument consists of his analysis on how to live the fullest life. He concurs that one must act in the name of purity and wellness (or good) in all situations. One must by strong, healthy and promote justice in his or her life to fufull a lifetime.

Although this was written over 2000 years ago, I believe that Plato's work is still relevant today. With a ubiquitous topic such as this one, many will indefinately keep analyzing their lives. I believe that Socrates contributes the best arguments and ideals on the discussion, for he is most confident and less likely to concur with the opposition. I found "Gorgias" to be slightly confusing in certain areas merely for the style of speech. With a deep analysis, however, I was able to sometimes find a valuable virtue to look up to.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Haley,

You seem to have a good grasp of the main ideas and arguments. I'm also glad that you are troubled by Callicles argument and the fact that you can't find an argument against it.....yet.

This is a topic that we will return to again and again....and again throughout the semester.